AI & digitalisation

Automation in your business: where it has a lasting impact and where it falls short

Moltomedia

Person symbolically buried under sticky notes and memos

*This graphic was partly created with the help of generative artificial intelligence and then edited manually

👉 Let's start from the beginning

Automation has long ceased to be a futuristic concept; it is now daily business in production, sales, marketing, and increasingly in administration as well. Nevertheless, studies concurrently report two completely different realities: on the one hand, there are companies that operate significantly more efficiently thanks to automation; on the other hand, an alarmingly high number of projects fail before any real impact can even unfold.

This presents a divided picture. The question is not whether automation is worthwhile, but where, how, and under what conditions.

🖥️ Process automation: The silent efficiency lever in the background

When people talk about automation, many first think of software that takes over repetitive tasks: invoice processing, quote generation, data entry. This is precisely where the greatest, best-documented effects currently lie. An analysis of process automation based on a Forrester study shows an ROI (return on investment) of 383% over three years, with a payback period of just six months. At the same time, according to the same evaluation, 78% of new automation projects in 2025 and 2026 are already relying on AI-augmented approaches rather than traditional, rules-based RPA solutions, because AI can also handle unstructured tasks such as emails or documents.


Time to escape the old way of working

*This graphic was created partly using generative artificial intelligence and subsequently edited manually


The German Mittelstand displays a complex and slightly contradictory status quo here. Current evaluations of KfW data indicate that around 31% of German SMEs use AI in their business, even though IT service providers, such as Neckar IT, promote ROIs of up to 350% purely through process automation.

⚙️ Production: Automation as an answer to the skilled labour shortage

In manufacturing, automation has long ceased to be an optional extra; for many companies, it is a necessity. The German Economic Institute predicts that by 2027, Germany will face a shortage of around 728,000 skilled workers. Alongside retail, childcare, and nursing, industrial fields such as electrical installation, construction planning, and warehouse logistics are particularly affected. Accordingly, the automatica Trend Index shows: roughly half of all employees in Germany see robotics and automation as a genuine opportunity to counter the skilled labour shortage, and 65% believe that it relieves staff from dangerous or hazardous tasks.

At the same time, the German robotics and automation industry itself is currently navigating a difficult phase: the VDMA Robotics + Automation Association anticipates a 5% decline in turnover to €14.1 billion for 2026, following a 7% drop the year before. However, according to the association, the long-term drivers—digitisation, AI, smart manufacturing—remain intact. Short-term investment reluctance and long-term structural necessity are not mutually exclusive here; they simply coexist at present.

📣 Marketing: Automation is becoming a must-have, not just a nice-to-have

The role of automation is also shifting noticeably in marketing. The latest Bitkom study, "Marketing in the Digital Transformation", reveals: 76% of surveyed companies expect marketing automation to become more important in the future, and 84% view AI as the most significant influencing factor for marketing in Germany. At the same time, 54% cite cost pressures and another 54% cite the automation of marketing processes itself as their greatest internal challenge—an indication that implementation in practice is often more complex than the trend suggests.

On an operational level, the benefits are nevertheless evident: according to practical analyses, small and medium-sized enterprises save up to 90 working days per year through marketing automation, such as automated email sequences and lead scoring. Furthermore, a three-person marketing team using suitable systems can manage tens of thousands of contacts without hiring additional staff.

⚠️ The other side: Why so many automation projects fail

Amidst all the enthusiasm for efficiency gains, one crucial point must not be overlooked: a considerable proportion of automation projects in the German Mittelstand fail to achieve their objectives. Current analyses point to a failure rate of around 43% for automation projects in SMEs. The primary reasons recur with striking frequency:

🎯 Legacy systems without modern interfaces: When legacy systems do not provide APIs, any automation turns into an improvised workaround rather than a stable solution.

Imagine this: you want order details to be transferred automatically to your ERP. However, the systems you use do not integrate easily, and the only interface available is an overnight CSV export managed through a third system. Your desired automation must bridge this gap, which can be accomplished using either middleware or a bespoke solution (and in such cases, you can naturally always turn to Moltomedia).

🎯 Lack of team acceptance: Automation succeeds primarily where employees recognise the benefits for their own work and are actively involved in selecting the processes—not where it is simply imposed on them.

Imagine this: you want to make life a little easier for your colleague in accounting, so you automate the billing process, which you consider tedious. The workflow implemented checks incoming payments, generates PDFs, sends them via email, and archives them in compliance with GDPR. Technically, it works within three days. However, your employee feels it is too risky not to double-check what is being dispatched. Consequently, they review every single invoice manually before it is sent. Thus, while the automation works flawlessly, it completely fails in its purpose of relieving the accounting colleague and taking billing off their desk.

🎯 Uncontrolled shadow automation: When individual teams introduce automation tools independently without IT governance keeping pace, new silos emerge instead of reduced friction—a pattern remarkably similar to the classic interface dilemma within organisations.

Imagine this: your employees want to work more efficiently, so they build workflows themselves within the applications they use—such as Excel macros—and even save them to their private Google accounts because the IT department lacks the capacity to assist. These workflows operate entirely outside of IT governance. There is no clear communication regarding what data is processed where, and no one has documented the logic, tested edge cases, or ensured that IT security requirements are met. Should these employees ever leave your company, access to those Excel workflows disappears overnight. At that point, you have no idea whether—or where—any data is stored.

🎯 Flawed prioritisation: Those who start with the most complex process rather than the one offering the highest and most easily measurable value will quickly lose confidence in the entire endeavour.

Imagine this: your company uses SAP Business One as its ERP system, Shopware for e-commerce, and you currently manage your product data in Excel spreadsheets that you and your team manually transfer into the other two systems. You decide to tackle the "biggest problem" right from the outset and initiate a fully automated PIM integration designed to synchronise product data, stock levels, and pricing in real time between SAP, a new PIM system, and Shopware. The project simultaneously affects procurement, sales, and IT, requires interface development on all three sides, and is initially scheduled for a four-month rollout.

Reviewing progress after six weeks brings… disillusionment… nothing is live yet. Your product data is still being maintained manually in Excel while your team works concurrently on the complex solution. Your sales team notices no difference in their day-to-day work, wonders what the project is actually achieving, and begins to question its value.

Yet a simple first step would have sufficed: automating the synchronisation of stock levels between SAP and Shopware—entirely without a PIM and without pricing logic—could have been implemented within two weeks.

Your sales team would have noticed the impact immediately: no more oversold items, no more manual stock checks. This quick, visible win would have built the confidence within your team needed to tackle the more complex PIM integration next—with employees who have already seen concrete proof that automation truly works. (In such cases, we at Moltomedia are also delighted to support you with expert advice and hands-on help.)

On top of this comes regulatory pressure: for AI-supported automation in a corporate context, clear requirements now apply regarding the transparency of decision-making logic, human oversight for critical operations, and traceable documentation. Under the EU AI Act, breaches of these obligations for high-risk AI systems can result in fines of up to €15 million or 3% of global annual turnover.

💡 What this means for your automation strategy – our Molto tips

  • Start with the process that delivers the greatest and most measurable impact, not the one that is technically the most exciting.

  • Invest in data quality before investing in tools, because automation merely amplifies what is already there. If it is based on inconsistent data, your new system may run reliably, but on a flawed foundation.

  • Involve your team from the very beginning. Acceptance often plays a far more critical role in success or failure than the chosen software.

  • Incorporate governance from day one—especially with AI-driven automation—rather than trying to bolt it on afterwards.

  • Treat automation as a continuous process, not a one-off project. According to current analyses, the greatest productivity gains stem from continuous iteration across multiple cycles, not from the initial release of a system.

💙 This is precisely where we at Moltomedia come in

We never view automation in isolation as a matter of software tools, but rather as an interplay of process analysis, system architecture, and the people who have to work with it every day. Whether it involves back-office process automation, interfaces between ERP, CRM, and shop systems, or AI-driven workflows: we first identify where automation will deliver genuine impact before discussing specific technologies. All under one roof, with a single point of contact and without any friction between multiple service providers.

Symbolische Darstellung von Mensch und KI, die zusammenarbeiten

*This graphic was created partly using generative artificial intelligence and subsequently edited manually

After all, the most expensive automation is the one that no one in the team understands or uses.

Where are you already automating in your business, and where are you still in the middle of the process? We would love to hear about your experiences.

🔗 Sources: Bitkom, "Marketing im digitalen Wandel: Zwischen Effizienz, Automatisierung & Wettbewerb" (2026) | abi consulting, analysis on AI process automation incl. Forrester figures on Celonis | Webentwickler.pro, analysis on workflow automation and failure rates in SMEs | GAIM Solutions, analysis on AI automation and KfW data on SMEs | VDMA Robotics + Automation, industry figures 2026 | Packaging Journal, automatica Trend Index on robotics and the skilled labour shortage | Robotikverband.de, IW forecast on the skilled labour shortage | Neckar IT, guide to process automation and ROI in SMEs | neomarketing.de, analysis on marketing automation in SMEs | EU Artificial Intelligence Act, Article 99: Penalties

Get the clarity you need to move your business forward now.

Start today with your free IT assessment and get a clear roadmap for your digital future in just a few days.

© 2026 Moltomedia. All rights reserved.