Make-or-buy consulting: buy or develop software?

Introduce an off-the-shelf product, have your own solution built, or combine both? We compare the options for your specific process: benefits, total cost, integration and future dependencies. You get a well-founded recommendation and a roadmap for implementation.

About 30 minutes. You describe your project and, if available, the quotes. We clarify what the decision depends on and what is still missing for the comparison.

Employee at a workstation in the Moltomedia office
Employee at a computer in the office

Two quotes. Two prices. But no comparison yet.

The off-the-shelf product is cheaper and quickly available. But an important part of your process doesn't fit. Custom development promises an exact fit, costs more at first and has to be maintained later.

Now it comes down to which gap really matters. A different screen layout may not be a problem. Manual rework on every order can become expensive over the years. Conversely, not every habit justifies its own software.

A sound make-or-buy decision therefore compares the same scope over the same period. It also takes into account the work that stays with your own team.

Why decide when there are three options?

A combination often works best: off-the-shelf for mature core functions, targeted development for the part that sets you apart. Whether that makes sense for you is examined, not assumed.

1

Off-the-shelf software

The core requirements are standard in the market and well covered.

What needs to be checked: process adjustments, limitations, running costs and data export.

2

Off-the-shelf with custom extensions

The standard framework fits, but individual functions or handovers are missing.

What needs to be checked: separable extensions, update compatibility and clear responsibilities.

3

Custom software

Requirements cannot be met economically with products on the market or create particular value.

What needs to be checked: development scope, maintenance, available skills and whether others can take it over.

Where does customisation pay off?

The most important question is: what does your software need to do particularly well so that your company works better or customers notice a difference?

That could be a configurator, a special order process, an internal specialist application or a connection between systems. Custom development can also pay off when an off-the-shelf product is available but permanently requires more adjustment and manual work.

For many general tasks, on the other hand, there are mature standard solutions. Here it can be cheaper to adapt the process instead of rebuilding well-known functions.

We therefore distinguish between essential requirements, commercially relevant specifics and past habits. This distinction prevents both overloaded custom developments and an off-the-shelf purchase with expensive gaps.

Workshop at a wall covered with colourful sticky notes

The calculation over the entire lifetime

We apply the same period, user group and scope to all options. This turns different quotes into comparable decision bases.

Off-the-shelf software

Start: setup, licences, rollout and data migration

Deviating requirements: configuration, modules, extensions or remaining manual work

Integration: setting up interfaces and maintaining them when things change

Ongoing operation: subscription or licence maintenance, hosting, support and updates

Employees: onboarding, process changes and dealing with gaps

Dependencies: vendor, product roadmap, pricing model and extension partners

Switching: data export, contract terms and replacement

Custom software

Start: concept, development, testing and data migration

Deviating requirements: implementation within the agreed scope; additional requests mean additional effort

Integration: developing interfaces and also maintaining them when things change

Ongoing operation: hosting, maintenance, support and further development

Employees: onboarding, rollout and, if necessary, your own documentation

Dependencies: architecture, key people and development partners

Switching: transferable rights, complete documentation and the effort of a handover

On the benefits side we look at processing time, errors and rework, available volume and the quality of the customer offering, among other things. Where assumptions are uncertain, we show several scenarios. A favourable base case alone is not a sufficient basis.

Four points that should be clarified before signing

Does the solution really fit your processes?

We test critical requirements against representative use cases. A feature in the product description isn't enough if it doesn't cover your specific edge case.

Does it fit your existing systems?

What matters is which data can actually be transferred, who operates a connection and what happens when one side is updated.

Will employees actually use it?

The departments affected are involved early on. Custom-developed software also has to be introduced, explained and tested in day-to-day work.

Can someone else take over later?

For off-the-shelf software we check export options, contract terms and exit routes. For custom development, usage rights, source code access, documentation and third-party components used belong explicitly in the agreement.

Your result: decision paper and roadmap

First, the decision paper

It compares the options against the same criteria. You receive costs and benefits with their assumptions, a recommendation with its reasoning and the conditions under which a different solution would make more sense.

Then the roadmap

For the chosen direction we describe the sequence, prerequisites, effort and next decisions. If the process or an existing interface should be improved first, that is exactly what the plan says.

Both results are understandable for management and IT and can be used without Moltomedia. You then decide who carries out the implementation.

How different a good decision can turn out

Off-the-shelf software

Michel Verlag

Off-the-shelf software for the ordering process

The B2B ordering process required customer-specific discounts, stock levels and a connection to the merchandise management system, among other things. The online shop was built on Shopware. The basic requirements did not have to be rebuilt individually.

Off-the-shelf + custom development

RAAB Publishing

Standard shop with a custom configurator

The shop uses a standard system. The configurator for personalised printed greeting cards is a custom development, complemented by a connection to the merchandise management system and automatic print file generation. This keeps the shop core standardised while the company's special offering is mapped individually.

In the project described, delivery time fell from 14 days to a maximum of 48 hours. This result relates to the entire improved process and is not a general promise for other projects.

Custom solution

Power Fitness

Choosing the form of the application deliberately

For training and nutrition plans and different roles for trainers and coaches, an initial technical assessment came first. The choice fell on a progressive web app. The example shows that the decision also includes which technical form a custom solution needs in the first place.

How we work together

1. Understand the project

In the free initial consultation we discuss your goal, requirements and existing quotes. We then define the scope of the consulting, the schedule and a fixed price.

2. Compare the options

We talk to the business department and IT, review relevant documents and calculate the options on the same basis. Where evidence is missing, we name the check that is needed.

3. Decide on the recommendation

We present the decision paper and address objections. For the chosen direction you receive a roadmap you can act on.

4. Start rollout or development

Implementation is a separate engagement. It can be carried out by your team, another partner or Moltomedia. Acceptance, testing, handover and later support are explicitly agreed for it.

What lies behind Moltomedia

We can develop software and introduce off-the-shelf products. That helps us assess both options, including their later maintenance. We know the effort involved in custom extensions as well as the consequences of an off-the-shelf solution whose gaps employees have to make up for every day.

Since 1995 we have combined consulting with our own implementation. We do not take commissions for product recommendations. We can offer the later implementation; the decision basis also works with another partner.

Laptop and notebook with Moltomedia branding

Frequently Asked Questions

Is custom software too expensive for SMEs?

That can only be judged by the scope and the alternatives. A targeted extension is something different from building a complete company platform from scratch. What matters is the total cost and benefit over the lifetime.

Can you also have just two existing quotes compared?

Yes. We first align on the scope and assumptions, and add any missing items. This often reveals that the proposals are intended to solve different problems.

Do we ultimately recommend our own development?

Only if it proves convincing in comparison. The recommendation is justified with criteria, calculations, and alternatives. The fact that we can implement both approaches does not replace this justification.

What if none of the options makes sense?

Then we name the actual bottleneck and recommend the next steps. Sometimes a better connection between existing systems or a clarified process is enough. If the first question is the fundamental choice of technology, technology consulting is the right fit.

How much does the consultation cost and how long does it take?

The scope depends on the requirements, the number of options and the systems involved. After the initial consultation you receive a quote with clear deliverables, a schedule and a fixed price.

Which option suits your project?

Whether you already have quotes or the requirement is still taking shape: tell us what the software should improve. In the free initial consultation we clarify which options can be compared and which information is still missing for the decision.

Moltomedia meeting room with conference table
Moltomedia meeting room with conference table

Get the clarity you need to move your business forward now.

Start today with your free IT assessment and get a clear roadmap for your digital future in just a few days.

© 2026 Moltomedia. All rights reserved.

Get the clarity you need to move your business forward now.

Start today with your free IT assessment and get a clear roadmap for your digital future in just a few days.

© 2026 Moltomedia. All rights reserved.

Get the clarity you need to move your business forward now.

Start today with your free IT assessment and get a clear roadmap for your digital future in just a few days.

© 2026 Moltomedia. All rights reserved.